Unearthing Wisconsin’s Whimsical Folklore: Legends of Bigfoot, Ghosts & More!

Discover the Story Behind Ishnala: Wisconsin's Top Supper Club Experience

Update Exploring Ishnala: Wisconsin's Quintessential Supper Club Nestled within the serene embrace of Mirror Lake State Park, Ishnala Supper Club stands as an enduring symbol of Wisconsin's cultural and culinary heritage. Recently highlighted in the Cabin Podcast, the establishment has not only earned its title as the #1 supper club in Wisconsin, but it has also developed a unique dining experience that draws both locals and visitors alike, eager to indulge in a night of excellent food, ambiance, and hospitality.In 'The Story Behind Wisconsin's #1 Supper Club: Ishnala', the podcast delves into the rich history and culinary delights of this iconic destination, inspiring us to unpack its charm for our readers. The Ishnala Experience: More Than Just a Meal Ishnala isn’t your typical restaurant; it’s an experience wrapped in a journey. Reaching the supper club involves a scenic drive through a wooded pathway that feels like you’re traveling back in time. The moment diners cross the Ishnala sign, they enter a world filled with nostalgia, warmth, and a sprinkle of adventure. The Proer family, who runs Ishnala, prides itself on not only serving delicious food but also upselling an atmosphere where families can make memories. The Menu: Local and Legendary Flavors The menu is a delightful homage to Wisconsin's culinary landscape, with a strong emphasis on local ingredients. According to co-owner Bob Proser, "We try to do as much local as possible," sourcing ingredients from nearby farms and suppliers. Diners flock to Ishnala to savor the famed 7 oz filet mignon — the establishment's star dish — alongside prime rib and ribeye steaks. But fear not, vegetarians: while not the main focus, accommodations are made to include gluten-friendly options. The magic really lies in how they enhance plain beef steak into a gourmet experience. The seasoned staff and their keen attention to detail make every meal extraordinary, confirming Bob's ethos: "It's not about the number of people we serve, but the number we please." This mantra resonates particularly well with visitors, many of whom return with family generations in tow, re-experiencing their childhood memories. Making Every Minute Count: The Waiting Experience In a world where instant gratification is often the expectation, Ishnala flips this narrative on its head. Reservations are a no-go here, and visitors should expect to wait—sometimes even up to two hours. But it’s not a boring wait. Guests are encouraged to enjoy the scenery, sip on one of their famous Ishnala Old Fashioneds, and engage with each other. They even have live music filling the air with melodies that drift harmoniously through the restaurant and bar areas. As Michael Proser puts it, “You come to our place to not be in a hurry.” While some diners may hesitate at the thought of a wait, the experience of relaxing with a cocktail and good company makes every minute fly by. The vibe is convivial, making it more than just a meal; it’s a mini-vacation in itself! Wisconsin Heritage: The History of Ishnala Dating back to 1953, Ishnala was built on a piece of land with a remarkable history, once a ceremonial ground for the Winnebago tribe. The establishment has changed hands since its inception, evolving under the guidance of the Hoffman Brothers. Each layer of history adds depth to the dining experience, offering patrons not just a meal, but a taste of Wisconsin's past. Today, Bob Proser shares the journey with his son, Michael. Their relationship mirrors the multi-generational ties that so many families have developed with Ishnala. From first dates to anniversaries, the restaurant has played a role in life’s major milestones, creating an oasis where families can come together time and again, no matter how life evolves. Future of Ishnala: Sustaining Excellence As Michael takes more of a leadership role in the business, he is committed to honoring their father's legacy while also embracing new opportunities in the catering world. Ishnala may not be changing much—but the passion for hospitality is constant. "We won’t sacrifice what makes us unique," he asserts, hoping to sustain that authentic Ishnala experience for years to come. Why You Should Visit Ishnala If you're planning your next Wisconsin vacation, Ishnala should be at the top of your list. The unique blend of mouthwatering food, warm hospitality, and the stunning backdrop of Mirror Lake is sure to leave an impression. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this supper club guarantees an unforgettable evening that captures the essence of Wisconsin tourism. So grab your appetite, put on your adventure hat, and head over to Ishnala, where every meal is a chance to make lasting memories. As they say in Wisconsin, "If it’s worth doing, it’s worth doing deliciously!" In conclusion, don’t just take our word for it—the next time you're in the area, be sure to experience Ishnala for yourself. We promise it’ll be an evening you won’t soon forget!